Current:Home > NewsSouth Carolina lawmakers rekindle bill limiting how topics like race are taught-LoTradeCoin
South Carolina lawmakers rekindle bill limiting how topics like race are taught
View Date:2024-12-24 10:59:57
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A small group of lawmakers in South Carolina rekindled debate Tuesday on a bill that would limit how topics like race can be taught in public school K-12 classrooms.
Both the House and Senate passed bills on the topic in 2023. But the different versions sat dormant until a conference committee met to try to work out the differences.
The three House members and three senators adjourned after an hour after making it just four pages into a 16-page handout on the differences between the proposals. There is a deadline. The regular session ends Thursday, although since a version of the bill passed both chambers it could survive into special sessions in June.
The conference committee Tuesday didn’t even get to the biggest differences between the chambers.
The Senate removed a provision requiring teachers to post any changes to their plans on what they will teach and classroom materials three days before the lessons and removed another provision allowing parents to sue any district in the state they think is teaching prohibited concepts even while they follow the school district’s appeal process.
The bill mostly copies a section first put in the state budget three years ago that prohibits teaching that one race is superior to another or race determining someone’s moral character.
The proposal does have an appeal process for material that parents find objectionable. But the Senate version limits the right to complaints to students, parents, employees or volunteers in the school district where the objectionable items are found.
Missing from the bill is the explicit phrase “ critical race theory.” It instead prevents teaching that an individual “bears responsibility for actions committed in the past” by other members of their race, and that someone is inherently privileged or should receive “adverse or favorable treatment” because of their race.
Supporters of the bill said nothing in it prevents teaching about any ethnic group’s history or the “fact-based discussion” of historical periods and current events. For example, teachers could include lessons about slavery and Jim Crow, but within the historical facts.
Democratic Sen. Darrell Jackson questioned whose historical facts would be considered, especially for topics like what caused the Civil War and if disagreements could lead to numerous challenges.
“Can you talk about how South Carolina was led by rich white slave owners who convinced uneducated white tenant farmers to join in the war?” Jackson said. “What caused the Civil War? Was it the Lost Cause? Was it states’ rights? Was it to defend slavery?”
Supporters said the goal of the bill is to give teachers parameters and balance that against the rights of parents to know what is being taught.
A sponsor of the bill, Republican Rep. Adam Morgan, didn’t give specific examples but he said he has heard about teachers who have taught one race is superior or should bear responsibility for what was done in the past.
“If my kid is in that class, if your kid is in that class, if somebody else’s kid in is that class — suddenly it’s a big issue,” Morgan said. “It’s not happening everywhere, but it’s happening somewhere.”
veryGood! (61)
Related
- Whoopi Goldberg calling herself 'a working person' garners criticism from 'The View' fans
- Georgia remains No. 1 after scare, Texas moves up to No. 2 in latest US LBM Coaches Poll
- Arizona man accused of online terror threats has been arrested in Montana
- Days of preparation and one final warning. How Kamala Harris got ready for her big debate moment
- Repair Hair Damage In Just 90 Seconds With This Hack from WNBA Star Kamilla Cardoso
- Prosecutors: Armed man barricaded in basement charged officers with weapon, was shot and killed
- Why Sofía Vergara Was Surprised by Her History-Making Emmy Nomination for Griselda
- Donald Trump Declares I Hate Taylor Swift After She Endorses Kamala Harris
- RHOBH's Erika Jayne Reveals Which Team She's on Amid Kyle Richards, Dorit Kemsley Feud
- Change-of-plea hearings set in fraud case for owners of funeral home where 190 bodies found
Ranking
- Lions find way to win, Bears in tough spot: Best (and worst) from NFL Week 10
- Georgia remains No. 1 after scare, Texas moves up to No. 2 in latest US LBM Coaches Poll
- Taylor Swift Is the Captain of Travis Kelce's Cheer Squad at Chiefs Game
- John Oliver Curses Out Emmy Awards on Live TV While Paying Tribute to Dead Dog
- Brian Austin Green’s Fiancée Sharna Burgess Celebrates Megan Fox’s Pregnancy News
- Another World Series hangover. Defending champion Rangers fail to repeat
- We went to almost 30 New York Fashion Week shows, events: Recapping NYFW 2024
- Profiles in clean energy: She founded a business to keep EV charging stations up and running
Recommendation
-
Brittany Cartwright Defends Hooking Up With Jax Taylor's Friend Amid Their Divorce
-
When does daylight saving time end? What is it? What to know about 'falling back'
-
Emmy Awards 2024 live updates: 'The Bear,' 'Baby Reindeer' win big early
-
Who Is In the Banana Costume at the 2024 Emmy Awards? How a Reality Star Stole the Red Carpet Spotlight
-
Trump has promised to ‘save TikTok’. What happens next is less clear
-
CMA Awards snub Beyoncé, proving Black women are still unwelcome in country music
-
2024 Emmys Hosts Dan Levy and Eugene Levy Beg You To Say Their Last Name Correctly
-
This city is hailed as a vaccination success. Can it be sustained?